1. Can Istihsaan be understood as ‘permitting of haram under necessity’ and/or ‘necessity has its own ruling’? Or is this another independent principle?
2. The definition of Istihsaan is: "This principle involves the preference of an opinion based on a circumstantial need over an opinion based on qiyas." Or "Istihsaan is when you have a ruling by qiyas giving you an untenable situation and there is a need for over rule." Based on these definitions, how did Ameer ul Mu'mineen Umar ibn al Khattab (radiAllahu anhu) suspend the punishment for theft when the rulings are directly mentioned in the Qur’an; how can this be considered as istihsaan?
3. It is the Sunnah of Allah to remove the difficulty from human beings. Do we have "specific" proofs in the Qur'an or Sunnah where Allah and/or Prophet Muhammed (salallaahu alaihi wasallam) approved principles such as Istihsaan since this principle was developed far later on; so does that mean that we practice it without having been given a green light for it?
Sometimes the legal preference (istihsan) can be between two textual proofs and this means it is not only restricted to qiyaas and textual proof (a verse from the Qur'an or a hadith).[1] Our Shari’ah is one which has given us laws which contain reasons and purposes and part of the purpose is that Allah always commands us what is beneficial to us (hasan/husn) and from this word (hasan) the word istihsan was derived. So it will be false to say istihsan is not referred to in the Qur'an or the Sunnah. Yes, we can agree that it wasn’t referred to directly but there is evidence that it was referred to indirectly. [2]
References:
[1] http://www.iium.edu.my/deed/lawbase/maliki_fiqh/usul8.html
[2] Dr B Philips, The Evolution of Fiqh, 82 - 85
< Back to Questions