1. Non-Muslims often ask to explain capturing wealth/women of other territories or killing people who did not harm the Muslims living in Madinah.

How do we answer this from the Qur’an or Sunnah?

2. Umar (may Allah be please with him) modified the divorce law in order to stop the alarming number of divorces that were erupting in the society.

Weren’t the laws laid down by the Prophet (salallaahu alaihi wasallam) not enough to handle this?

3. The hadith of the Prophet (salallaahu alaihi wasallam) tells us to follow his Sunnah and then the Sunnah of the rightly guided caliphs.

Doesn’t it become incumbent on us to follow the ruling made by Umar (may Allah be pleased him)?

If not, then what is the true understanding of the above hadith?

Please find my answers below:

  1. Each verse in the Qur'an must be understood in context. The verses the non-Muslims quote actually refer to the situation in a state of war. In times of war, different rules apply and this is something which is not restricted to Islam only. The Shari’ah has given us the best ways of dealing with the prisoners of war, and each is treated differently according to certain conditions.

It is not as if the Muslims are out looking for the kuffar infidels to kill. No, that is not our deen. The Prophet (ﷺ) always commanded the troops to first call them to Islam, if they refused, to tell them about jizyah and then finally to fight them. If what certain non-Muslims say is the truth, then the Prophet's (ﷺ) command would be to kill them all. When Christians pose such questions, I usually ask them to also explain it from their book, for example: [1]

“As you approach a town to attack it, first offer its people terms for peace. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. But if they refuse to make peace and prepare to fight, you must attack the town. When the Lord your God hands it over to you, kill every man in the town. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. You may enjoy the spoils of your enemies that the Lord your God has given you.”
  1. Only Allah knows best how the divorce laws helped. The reason behind Umar's (ra) move was that people were playing around and hurting the feelings of women. For example, men used to frequently pronounce divorce three times in one sitting. The new law stated that if a man pronounced divorce thrice, his wife would become haram for him. This meant the man had to be serious about what he was uttering. So, I would say, it is not about whether what the Prophet (ﷺ) had given the people what was sufficient or not. Rather, it is about trying to provide the best solution that is also suitable to the contemporary challenges, which realizes the maqasid of shariah.
  2. The Sunnah of the Khulafah Rashidun is the Sunnah of the Prophet (ﷺ) and most importantly, the one we were all (including all the Sahabah) commanded to follow was the Prophet (ﷺ) and no one else. The scholars have stated that the preponderant opinion is that three talaqs in one sitting are regarded as one talaq only, because of the statement from the Prophet (ﷺ). However, we have to remember that our fiqh is flexible and that the aim of the Shari’ah is to give people the best remedy to any situation. [2]
  References:

[1] Deuteronomy 20:10-14

[2] Sheikh S Al-Fawzan, A Summary of Islamic Jurisprudence, 2/388

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram