Is it permissible to follow the rulings of different madhabs for different issues?
For us to understand the issue of madh-habs, we have to first identify two things:
- That Allah commanded us to follow the Prophet (ﷺ).
- Each person is different from the other but what we know is there are three main groups where we fit. We are either laymen, students of the religion or mujtahids.
Most of us are laymen, and as laymen we have to ask the people of knowledge, and follow the ulama. Personally I think this is what is regarded as [1] and this has to be for a specific time. This is not blind following.
Then we start to learn, and we reach a stage where we know the different proofs used by the different scholars. If the scholar I am following says something and I come to know through another reliable scholar that there is another opinion which is supported by a daleel then I should be flexible enough to leave what my Imaam was saying or had said and follow the opinion which is supported by a more authentic and strong daleel. We can call this a mixing of madh-habs or it can be regarded as correctly following the daleel (ittiba).
In brief, there is a point of departure when you follow something without knowing the daleel but you follow what you learn, and this is taqleed. Then there is a stage where you know the proofs used and you follow the one supported by the strongest proof and this is ittiba. [2]
So, you will have to learn more, but it is impractical for us to learn all at one time. Therefore, the best would be to follow what you have learnt now and implement the new things you learn as you progress with your studies.
I hope you will find this information useful.
References:
[1] Dr B Philips, The Evolution of Fiqh, pp 138
[2] Dr B Philips, The Evolution of Fiqh, pp 180
< Back to Questions