1. Why are 2 different punishments prescribed for the same crime of zina in case the sinner is married and unmarried?

2. Some scholars say that since we don’t have caliphate anywhere in world or since we are not living under the rule of caliphates anymore, if someone commits fornication (any form) and later repents his sin might be forgiven by Allah. Is this an appropriate conclusion?

3. In Muslim countries if someone commits fornication and is caught red handed that person is sentenced to jail for some period of time or in rape cases sentenced to death which is usually western style "hang till death".

Do such punishments remove the gravest sin as it is not prescribed in Quran / Sunnah despite that person repenting?

  1. These 2 different punishments are not for the same sin. Zina can either be done by one who is married or by one who is not married. The former is regarded as adultery and the latter is known as fornication. It is Allah who has prescribed two different punishments for these two different crimes and only He best knows why. We can also see that the one who is married has a legal avenue to satisfy his desires so he/she does not a valid excuse when he/she satisfies his/her desires illegally.[1]
  2. I don’t think it’s an appropriate conclusion. If the right structures are put in place and the state (whether it has a Caliph or a King) is an Islamic state, meaning its constitution is based on what Allah and His Messenger said then the correct penalty can and should be carried out. Having a Caliph is not a condition for the penalties to be carried out, by having a state which has a recognized leader is adequate.[2]
  3. Putting someone in jail while it is not mentioned in the authoritative sources is something that has been deemed as acceptable by the scholars since it does not contradict the principles of Islamic law. With regards to hanging someone till death, this I think is not permissible because for such a crime the Shariah has prescribed a punishment.[3]

References:

[1] Sheikh S Al-Fawzan, A Summary of Islamic Jurisprudence, 2/593

[2] Sheikh S Al-Fawzan, A Summary of Islamic Jurisprudence, 2/587

[3] Sheikh S Al-Fawzan, A Summary of Islamic Jurisprudence, 2/590

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram