Will it not be better for Muslims to marry Shia’ who are at least closer to Islam is a broader sense rather than Christians and Jews?
The ruling on whether the Shia’ are Muslims or not is very sensitive and complex. Some are regarded as non Muslims while some according to the ‘ulama can be regarded as Muslims. Some among them believe that Ali was divine and had divine qualities, that all the sahabah except a few became murtads, that the Qur'an we have today is incomplete, etc. Just looking at these things one can say; how can someone who has these beliefs be regarded as a Muslim. To believe that Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) was divine is shirk, what more about Ali! Also one of their principles of faith is Taqiyah which to them means you should lie about almost everything. Now I am sure no bride or groom would prefer being married to someone like that? [1]
As for the Jews and Christians, we marry them because Allah and His Prophet (ﷺ) have told us that it is permissible to do so.[2] It is Allah who has mentioned them as ahl al-kitaab and it is He who has given them a different status from the other kuffar. So a person is either a Muslim or a non Muslim; if they are a non Muslim then they are either from ahl al-kitab or not. So if the Shia’ are regarded as non Muslims, we have to find out if they are ahl al kitab or not. But, I don’t think they are so which means we are not permitted to marry them.
Finally, it is not up to us to say if it is better to marry them or no.
References:
[1] http://islamqa.info/en/10941
[2] http://islamqa.info/en/44695
< Back to Questions