We know that the Prophet (ﷺ) had suspended making a bequest once the inheritance laws with specific proportions were revealed and laws were implemented.
What would be the ruling for a present day scenario in non-Muslim countries like USA who deal with the inheritance of the dead according to their laws?
A Muslim can still make a will and bequeath his wealth (a portion of it to anyone). The Shari’ah however restricts the testator in two ways:
- He can only bequeath to some people and not all.
- The bequest cannot be more than one third of the estate.
Abu Dawood reported that the Prophet (ﷺ) "... no bequest can be made to an heir."
The Prophet (ﷺ) also stated that the bequest must not be more than one third. [Bukhari]
"There is nothing in English or US law to prevent a Muslim making a valid will so that his/her estate is distributed according to Shari’ah. In fact, in such situations, a written valid will becomes absolutely necessary for Muslims" [1]
So, the Shari’ah does permit the testator to leave a will as long as it is within the boundaries of the Shari’ah. The best thing for a Muslim is to leave a valid will because if he/she was to die intestate (without a will or with an invalid) then the Intestate Succession Rules of that country apply.
Only Allah knows best.
Reference:
[1] Dr.A Hussain, Islamic Law of Succession, 385 - 386
< Back to Questions