Are we allowed to use counters or beads during memorization of the Qur’an and also during tawaaf?
It is all right to count in any way which does not involve sin - without taking any particular way or thing as part of the religion. In other words, where things have been left open-ended and unspecified, it is not permissible to specify anything, prefer it over others or attach significance to it without clear cut evidence from the Qur'an and the authentic hadeeth.
In our case, prayer beads and dhikr counters have had some significance attached to them and they have become associated with religion and worship despite the fact that they have no valid basis in Islam, but were adopted by adherents of other religions earlier.
In the light of the above, and bearing the safer position in mind, it would be best for a person's religion and his adherence to the Sunnah and the way of the Companions, to avoid using these dhikr beads and counters altogether.[1]
- Instead, if one is in doubt, he should take the lesser number and complete an extra round, humiliating the Shaitaan thereby and acquiring an extra reward, inshaaAllaah.
- In the case of a person who is forgetful, he can rely on the count of his companion if he forgets.
- If, for some reason, the above legislated ways cannot be followed, a person may count on anything, like the end of his garment, his fingers, the amount of supplications he has finished making, the number of pages of his supplication book he has finished, and so on - without attaching significance to any one of them.
To illustrate the 3rd point, I would hold the object putting one finger on the surface of a book, bag, phone, etc, in the first round, then two... until the fifth when I would grasp it with all of the fingers of my right hand. Then, I would hold it putting one finger of my left hand on it in the sixth round, and holding it casually with my left hand in the seventh and final round.
So you see, if you take care to find out and follow the legislated ways while dreading and shunning all that is not legislated and possibly innovated, you will, inshaaAllaah, find before you a myriad of acceptable ways where previously none but the innovated way may have appeared to exist!
Thus, in any issue, only if all of the legislated alternatives are exhausted (which is hardly ever the case) should we consider moving to something whose validity is doubtful or unestablished and only in cases where it is absolutely necessary as there is no other choice left.
Finally, always bear in mind that if you forget the number of adhkaar, raka'aat, soorahs, rounds of tawaaf, and so on and take the lesser number and complete the remaining part, you would have done nothing objectionable according to anyone, but instead would have earned more reward![2] On the other hand, adopting a way or method that is not legislated in the Qur'an and the Sunnah without necessity and failing to consider the legislated alternatives may very well result in sin.
And Allaah knows best.
References:
[1] http://islamqa.info/en/3009
[2] This is based on the fact that the lesser number is the number which is certain and the evidence for that is what was narrated by Abu Sa‘eed Al-Khudri , who said: “The Prophet (ﷺ) said: ‘If one of you has doubts during his prayer and he does not recall how many rak‘ahs he has prayed, whether three or four, then should forget about his doubt and complete his prayer on the basis of that of which he is certain, and then make two sujood before the salaam. If it turns out that he had prayed five rak‘ah, the two sujood would make it even, and if he ended up completing his four rak‘ahs , they would be in defiance of the Shaytaan.’” (Saheeh Muslim, Hadith 571)
< Back to Questions
Google+
Facebook
WordPress