Groups involved in Islamic activities encourage people to leave their families and go in the path of Allah. How far is this correct?

This perspective is found in one of the common groups, which are involved in Islamic activity in many communities around the world, wherein people are encouraged to go in the path, as they call it في سبيل الله , to leave their homes for 40 days or 4 months or so. What happens in many places is that brothers in their enthusiasm to be in the path of Allah, will leave their families in a state of destitution; the family has no means, they have not left sufficient money, etc.These people have taken off in the path of Allah for self purification, to become closer to Allah, to improve their religion; but this act, though the intention on the surface appears to be a good intention and praiseworthy, Islam does not favor it; it favors that the individual stay at home and look after his or her family rather than going out and leaving the family in a state of destitution.

To substantiate this, the following hadeeth is given as an example.

‘Umar Ibn Al Khattab stated that the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) had ordered them to give in charity. ‘Umar went to Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) and brought with himself, what he had just managed to earn - half of his money, and presented it to the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) who asked him, “What have you left for your family?”Umar replied, "I have left the similar amount." The Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) said, “Fine.” Then Abu Bakr came and gave everything that he had: all his money. The Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) asked Abu Bakr, “What have you left for your family?” So he said, "I have left Allah and his Messenger."[1]

The context here is that due to certain circumstances, a dire need for charity had risen. Hence, ‘Umar thought that this was his chance to beat Abu Bakr; to beat him in the sense that he thought himself to be in competition with Abu Bakr, to outdo him in righteousness; this competition is perfectly allowable.

This example, if we were to be applied realistically, would destroy the families of the Muslim society. We have to understand that this is a special case for Abu Bakr. This is not the rule; this is an exception to the rule. A special circumstance arose and because of who Abu Bakr was, the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) took it from Abu Bakr. It was an example to the ‘Ummah of the level of sacrifice that Abu Bakr was prepared to make; showing why he deserved to be the leader of Muslims after the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) and the reason for Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) to say that if he were to take a best friend, Abu Bakr would be his best friend.[2]

There are many other examples, when people came to Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) and wanted to give away all the money and he prohibited them from doing so. Saad Ibn Abi Waqqas, for example, was one of the major figures in the Islamic ‘Ummah. He had said, “In the year of the victory of Mecca I felt ill and was at the point of death, when the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) came to visit me and I said, ‘O Messenger of Allah, I have an abundance of wealth, and no one to inherit from me except my two daughters, May I bequeath all of my wealth in the way of Allah’. The Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) said, ‘No’, I enquired then a half, then Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) said, ‘No’, I asked, then a third, then the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) said, one third, but one third is still too much, that you leave your heirs free from want is better than leaving them poor to beg from people, you will be rewarded for everything you spend seeking Allah’s pleasure even for the morsel of food you place in your wife’s mouth.”[3]

Here we have the Prophet Mohammed (ﷺ) prohibiting Saad from giving all wealth or even half of his property. We have to understand that this example of Abu Bakr was a special case, and people who use it and try to make it a general rule and encourage people to make those kind of sacrifices are misunderstanding the context in which the hadeeth came and the state or the level that Abu Bakr was on in the eyes of Prophet Muhammed (ﷺ).

We also have another example, quoted by Jafar Ibn Abdullah, in which he said, ‘A man from Uzra, the Uzra clan, willed that his slave be free when he died. When this news reached, the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) , he asked the man, ‘Do you have any other wealth’, the man replied, “No”, Allah’s messenger (ﷺ) then said, ‘Who will purchase him from me?’ Naon ibn Abdullah bin Adwi bought the slave for 800 dirhams. Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) brought it and gave it to the man and said, “Give it in charity beginning with yourself, if any is left over give it to your family, if any is left over after giving it to your family, give it to your relatives, and then after that you may give here and there.” [4]

So we see the concern which Islam has for looking after the family, because the family is the core to society; the society as a whole cannot look after each and every individual family. When unusual circumstances arise in the society, then the society rises to the occasion to look after the family. We also cannot take the communist proposal whereby in a society nothing is owned by the individuals, it is rather owned collectively, and in this situation a society is responsible for each and every individual. This theory does and will not work. It is not practical. It is much more practical and much more in keeping with human nature that each individual has a family obligation that he or she looks after, and when those unusual circumstances arise, then the state may step in and help those who are in a position of need, and this is the general rule.

References:

[1] Sahih Al-Bukhari 3657 and Sahih Muslim 2383

[2] Sahih Muslim, Book 2 , Hadith 2

[3] Sahih Muslim, Book 25, Hadith 6

[4] Sunan An-Nasai, Book 44, Hadith 204

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
Loading Facebook Comments ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram