Can one have multiple intentions for a single fast that is, making up for a missed Ramadan fast as well as the fast of Ashura?
Also, is it permissible to have the intention of praying Salatul Hajjat or Salatul Shukr while praying Salatul Ishraq?
I am of the opinion that it is permissible and valid to have multiple intentions for a single fast. It will be accepted for both intentions, based on the Hadith, “Every action is judged by its intention and a man will have that which he intended,” [1]
As for Salaah, I do not know. From my understanding, it would be accepted, and Allah knows best. However, keep in mind though that many scholars believe there isn't such a thing as Salah Al-Haajat or Salah Ash-Shukr, because the ahadith which this Salaah is derived from has been declared weak by some scholars.
Technically speaking, if we pray Salaah the proper way then every Salaah we pray does contain Shukr (gratitude to Allah), Tawba (repentance to Allah) and Haajat (seeking assistance from Allah) so there wouldn't be a need to invent a specific form of Salaah for each of these since they are supposed to be a part of every Salaah any way.
The Shariah does have a concept called Sajdah Shukr, which is to fall into Sajdah out of gratitude whenever you receive some good news. This is done without any need of Wudhu or praying a formal Salah. It is just a prostration of gratitude. Abu Bakrah saw the Prophet (ﷺ), when news reached him that his troops had prevailed over their enemy, he was lying with his head in Ayesha’s lap, then he got up and fell into prostration. [2]
Allah knows best.
References:
[1] Saheeh Bukhari 1:1:1
[2] Musnad Ahmad, 5/45; al-Haakim, 4/291
< Back to Questions