Can rulings for a certain issue, for example, smoking cigarettes, change from time to time?

Yes, such rulings can change from time to time. Muslim scholars have categorized day to day acts into five categories of legal sunnah:

  • Waajib/ Fard- Compulsory
  • Sunnah/ Mustahab- Recommended
  • Mubah-Allowed
  • Makrooh-Disliked
  • Haram- Prohibited

If we take the issue of "smoking", smoking ganja and marijuana is totally haram. In the case of smoking cigarettes, some say it is haram while others regard it as makrooh.

Muslims first started using tobacco during the time of the Ottomans. They found that cigarettes only cause bad breath, so they went to the Shari’ah to find out the ruling that the Prophet (ﷺ) stipulated for something which causes bad breath, for example, garlic and onion. They found out that it is prohibited to go to the masjid in the case of bad breath because it will make fellow Muslims uncomfortable. So, the scholars at that time gave the same ruling for tobacco as being makrooh, i.e,. something which is disliked.

A few years ago, after extensive research, the medical community found out that smoking causes cancers and cancers kill people; therefore smoking cigarettes kills people. So, the ruling needs to be changed. Based on the new information, smoking cigarettes falls under a new category and it is the category of poison. Now we need to look at the ruling for poisons in the Shari’ah. It is haram to take poison as the Prophet (ﷺ) said that whoever kills himself will end up in Hell.

It was narrated from Thaabit ibn al-Dahhaak (radiAllahu anhu) that the Messenger of Allaah (ﷺ) said:

“Whoever kills himself with something in this world will be punished with it on the Day of Resurrection.” [1]

You know what you are taking is haram if it kills you.

Something can be haram for some people while it is halal for others, for example, sugar. For a diabetic person, sugar is haram but for a normal person it is halal. Islamic law depends on the evidence of the effect. Someone may say that not all people who smoke get cancer, and they may give the example of the 105 year old lady who smoked cigars and drank alcohol everyday and did not have cancer. In this case, we have to say that it was Allah's wish. Most people die because of smoking cigarettes, and Allah kept her alive in order to show us that He can do the opposite too. The very thing which kills everyone might not kill you, but we are obliged to deal with cause and effect.

Source: Hadith & Fiqh

Reference:

[1] Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 5700; Muslim, 110

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram