What are the characteristics and responsibilities of a righteous imam ?
Can a woman have the position of authority?
One who is just in himself and his rule [1]. His justice is not for a show or to establish relationships with others with ulterior motives. His justice is based fundamentally on the fear of Allah. He treats all justly, he repels oppression, all before him are equal, and implements Allah’s laws on the entire creation over which he has authority. His justice is from within and it is not external justice in order to gain certain positions, control, power or wealth in this life. This is the position of Imam al-Adil,the ultimate ruler of the Muslim state-who is just.
Of course, this does not include women, because Prophet (ﷺ) has said that, “The people who make their women rulers will not succeed.” [2] In this category -the head of state- women are excluded. However, Prophet (ﷺ) said, “كلكم راعٍ” meaning each and every one of you is like a shepherd responsible for his folk. [3] So, each one plays the role of being an imam, he is a leader who has people who follow him or her. She in her home is in charge of the home and those under her authority. The issue of being just is still valid in her case in this regard. Abdullah ibn Umar ibn ul as narrated from Prophet (ﷺ) that, “the just people will be on the podium of lights from the lights of Ar-Rahman and both his hands are right. Those who are just in their ruling and in their families and in what they have put their authority over.” [4] That those who are just in the rulings they make, in the position of authority, whether it be within their families or outside, they will be put into a special position on the day of judgment on podiums of light beside being under the shade of Allah’s throne. Following the judgment they will be in the podium of lights on the right of Ar-Rahman.
Special importance- because the imam, the ruler, the authority has no fear of anyone, any human being because of what they do, the right thing or judge justly. They are in the position which is easily exploited, which is easily abused, and it is very easy when the person is in the higher level or on top of the organization, state, family, to abuse the position of authority and power, because they are not accountable to anyone. So, it is only one who senses the accountability towards Allah, who fears Allah, who seeks to please Allah- such an individual, will be able to be just in spite of whatever circumstances arises before himself or herself.
Abu Hurayah narrated that Prophet (ﷺ) said, “There are three whom Allah will not reject their duas. There are 3 groups whose supplication will not be turned down, one who remembers Allah often, the oppressed, and the just imam.” These are all in special categories. But at the same there are for whom Allah is angry with. As narrated by the Prophet (ﷺ); “The trader who frequently swear by Allah, everything he sells you he says ‘Wallahi’- this is a good product, by Allah you have the best thing here in the market, such a person is hated by Allah”. “ The proud pauper” , the one who is poor, destitute, and instead of being humbled by his state of destitution he is proud, in spite of it all he is proud and he is haughty, such an individual is hated by Allah. That is the situation where pride has no place. Destitution, poverty is a means of humiliating people, bring pride down low to their knees, but such an individual in spite of this all, maintains an aura of pride. They try to live beyond their means to create fasad [5] around them. Creating the impression that they are doing well, they are this, that or the other. Such a person is hated by Allah. “The adulterous old man”, He didn’t just say the adulterer, but the adulterous old man. Meaning the man who grows old, who knows better, who rarely has no justification for adultery, not that there can be any justification. But in the sense that a young person driven by hormones etc., may commit such mistakes because of all pressure on them, but the old man who doesn’t have such pressures; he has nothing pushing him to adultery, but he still falls into adultery such an individual is particularly hated by Allah. “And the sin full Imam”; Imamun Jahir the leader who is corrupt. One who Allah has placed in his hands, power, control, authority, abuses that control, such an individual is particularly hated by Allah.
References:
[1] For details about the requirements for a caliph see : Islamic Politics, Sheikh Mujahid At-Tamimiy
[2] Narrated by Abu Bakra “During the battle of Al-Jamal, Allah benefited me with a Word (I heard from the Prophet). When the Prophet heard the news that the people of the Persia had made the daughter of Khosrau their Queen (ruler), he said, "Never will succeed such a nation as makes a woman their ruler." Sahih Bukhari, 4425
[3]Abdullah bin Umar reported: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said, “Every one of you is a shepherd and is responsible for his flock. The leader of the people is a guardian and is responsible for his subjects: a man is the guardian of his family and is responsible for his subjects, a woman is the guardian of her husband’s home and of his children and is responsible for them, and the slave of a man is a guardian of his master’s property and is responsible for it. Surely, every one of you is a shepherd and responsible for his flock.” (Sahih Bukhari 6719; Sahih Muslim 1829)
[4] Sahih Muslim, 1827
[5] corruption, or crimes against law and order in the Muslim community
< Back to Questions