1. "Ijtihad was not there during presence of Prophet Muhammad (salallaahu alaihi wasallam) and even if it was there it can’t be regarded as source of law."
But doesn’t this contradict the hadith wherein there was confusion among the Sahaba on understanding the Prophet’s statement about praying ‘Asr on a journey that they were on?
According to the hadith, both the groups decided on what to do based on ijtehad?
2. If ijtihad can’t be taken as a base for ruling, then what about that which the current scholars derive based on ijtihad?
3. Was the opinion of all the 4 Imams purely based on ijtihad?
If yes, then how we take any of the 4 Imams rulings as basis of legislation?
Aren’t ijtihad / fatwa / opinion in true sense human extraction from divine revelation; then basing our legislation on a fatwa isn't it basing it on understanding of some human instead of Allah?
4. What is evidence of basing our rulings on previous rulings by other human?
- First let’s define the word Ijtihad. Ijtihad is “the independent or original interpretation of problems not precisely covered by the Qurʾān and/or Sunnah.[1] So, in a nutshell we can refer to ijtihad as a process by which a scholar deduces laws or legal principles from the sources of law. The scholar is not making the laws but he is trying to retrieve the laws. This means that, during the time of the Prophet (ﷺ), even if Ijtihad was taking place, everything was referred back to the Prophet (ﷺ) since he was receiving revelation. With revelation available, there was no need to deduce any law, what you needed to know you had to ask the one who received revelation.
Regarding the hadith, the two groups deduced from the words of the Prophet what they were ordered to do. So both groups did interpret the words of the Prophet (ﷺ) and because Ijtihad was not a source of law during the era of the Prophet (ﷺ) they had to refer the issue back to the Prophet (ﷺ). This means that there is no contradiction between what Ijtihad is and what happened between the two groups
- Based on what we said above, Ijtihad plays a very essential role in availing us rulings and solutions for contemporary issues. If you look closely at what we discussed in the Live Sessions, you will notice that Qiyas, Istihsan, Istishab[2] etc are all part of Ijtihad, and this means that the scholars efforts are valid provided that what they give us does not contradict the Qur’an and Sunnah.
- Allah said:" Ask the people of knowledge." So since we do not know ourselves then following a madhab in that instance is something that can be obligatory as we are not equipped with the tools needed for ijtihad. What the scholars ( 4 Imaams and others) were doing was to deduce the laws and not make laws, they interpreted the text but they were not makers of the law. By following their rulings we are in fact following the commandment of Allah to “ask the people of knowledge”. If you on the other hand can do your own deductions, meaning you are a mujtahid then you are allowed or it becomes obligatory for you to deduce yourself and it thus become prohibited for you to follow deductions of any other mujtahid. [3]
- The ideal situation is whereby each one of us when faced with a situation: to deduce a ruling ourselves from the Qur'an and the Sunnah but fact is: we do not have the basic knowledge and thus it becomes compulsory to ask those who know and those who know include the four Imaams and our pious predecessors. Basis of our legislation is not any of the 4 Imaams but it is the Qur'an and the Sunnah, the 4 Imaams are just like teachers who will help us in understanding the basis of our legislation. So the proof will be : our lack of knowledge and that Allah has commanded us to ask the people of knowledge if we know not. [4]
[2] http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/297047/istihsan
[3] Dr B Philips, The Evolution of Fiqh, p 56
[4] Evolution of Fiqh, p59
< Back to Questions