Are we allowed to sit in a car and pray due to considerations that make standing and praying outside of the car uncomfortable, or people walk in front or people may look at you.

You are shy to have people looking at you while praying and all these other things. So you want to sit in the car and pray. Well, Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)  had said:

“The prayer of one sitting is one half of the one standing” [1]

So, if you are okay with giving up half, then go for it. It is permissible, but you will lose half the reward. It is different from when you are in the airplane, as this is a different situation. Inside the airplane, we will not stand up between the rows and pray. You cannot do it there, and so this situation is different. Alternatively, the only other places you can stand are in front of the toilet. No, you are not going to go and stand there and pray.

First, I understand this principle here. Your standing is where it is possible to stand, and you are choosing not to because you are embarrassed. Alternatively, you are at the airport you know the time for prayer comes, you are the only Muslim there, you feel shy to go over and just make your prayer. Therefore, you sit in the seat and make your prayer. You do that, it is worth half the reward of standing. However, where it is not possible to pray standing, due to real factors, then you are excused.

Now in terms of facing the Qibla, we know Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) prayed on the back of a donkey, on the back of the horse, and there is no mention that he kept on turning the horse to Qibla the whole time he was praying. It is not mentioned like that at all. He prayed wherever the horse went. It is not a requirement in such circumstances.

Some people say that sitting in prayers is only allowed for voluntary prayers. This is a claim that cannot be established. Did Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)  sit and pray fard obligatory prayer? Did Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) pray sitting? Yes, only when he was sick. Therefore, that is sufficient evidence. The point that we are talking about is whether it is permissible to pray fard sitting. It is permissible.

The principle is you are permitted to sit and pray in the plane or in other circumstances. Even if you chose to sit and pray, the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)  has already told us the reward is half. You lose half of the prayer. Standing and praying, and sitting and praying is permissible. In the airplane where standing is not possible, you sit and pray, and you get the full reward because the reward is only decreased where you are sitting at the place where you could actually stand. That is the basic principle.

So, in a circumstance where you can stand but you choose to sit, that does not nullify your prayer. It nullifies half of the reward of your prayer. In the areas of Ijtihaad, beware of trying to push the opinion of some scholars which may not be agreed upon by other scholars. You can have one opinion, and you can go with the one you feel is stronger to you, that is okay. However, when you are going to come (saying) your Salah is not good, not acceptable, it is a difficult one to take.

Reference:

[1] Sunan Ibn Maajah:  Vol. 1, Book 5, Hadith 1229

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram