“Four [groups of people] will be brought [before Allaah] on the Day of Resurrection: the newly born, the mentally insane, those who died in the period between two messengers, and the senile. Each will present his case. Then the Lord will tell a flame from the Hellfire to come out. He will then say, ‘I used to send to My slaves messengers from among themselves. Today I am My own messenger to you. So enter this fire.’ Those destined for Hell will say, ‘Our Lord, how can we enter it when we were supposed to escape from it?’ Then the ones destined to be happy will rush forth and jump into it without hesitation. Allaah will say to those who refused, ‘You would have been even more disbelieving and disobedient to My messengers.’ Then He put the second group [i.e. those who obeyed Allaah and jumped in] in Paradise, and the first group in the Hellfire.”

How will Allah test these groups on the Day of Judgment in this manner? Is this test based on trust in Allah? Does this mean that those who disobeyed His command and did not enter the fire are equivalent to those who did not obey the Messengers in dunya?

What Allaah reveals to us, His slaves, carry two things: information and/or commands.

As far as information and news are concerned, the slave’s duty is only to believe in them and affirm their truth. As far as commands are concerned, the slave’s duty is only to follow and implement them in obedience to His creator.

That is all there is to it.

After a person knows that the information or command is truly from Allaah and he understands what it is saying, he has no excuse to refuse believing in it or implementing it. It is only if the person, to the extent of his ability, cannot ascertain the authenticity of the information’s ascription to Allaah or the intended meaning and application of the command, that he may be excused.

Here, in this case, we have Allaah in front of these people speaking to them, so there is no doubt as to the authenticity. What Allaah means by his command is also very clear; they have no doubt about it whatsoever. Therefore, there is only one thing left and they will have gained Allaah’s pleasure and saved themselves – to follow the command in obedience to Allaah, since they know it is from Him and what He means by it.

However, they object – not invoking either of the above two excuses, or even claiming that it is simply outside their ability, but because the command does not fit in their intellect’s scheme of things – how can it be that entering a flame (which is not hell but taken out from it for testing them) can be advantageous to them and ensure their success and salvation.

Consider, why Iblees refused to obey Allaah’s command to prostrate before Adam – not because he did not know if the command was really from Allaah or what He actually meant by it, but because it did not make sense to Him why a being made from fire should humble himself before a creature made from mud!

Ibn-ul-Qayyim [1]and Ibn Katheer[2] mention that this test is like the test of the Dajjaal when he will present the people with what appears to be hell and what appears to be paradise, and those who enter what appears to be fire, believing the Prophet (ﷺ) and obeying his command would, in fact, be entering paradise, while those who believe the Dajjaal and enter what appears to be paradise will, in fact, be entering hell!

So whoever would have believed and obeyed had the message reached him in this world will obey there on the Day of Judgement, and whoever would have refused to believe and obey had the message reached him in this world will disobey Allaah there.

As for the intellect, it can be used to affirm Allaah’s existence, His sole right to worship, His unique oneness and certain other fundamentals of faith. However, it can neither be used to deduce the details of the religion, nor to argue against what Allaah has revealed after one knows it is from Him and what it means. Then, what is required is to simply believe and obey. This is because even if the information or command does not appeal to the person’s logic, it is very likely that his reasoning is faulty, but it can never be that Allaah will ask him to believe what is not true or command him to do what is not correct! Should He who created us not know what is ultimately better for us?

In other words, it is not a must that we understand each and every test that Allaah gives us or why he would test us by commanding us to do something which may appear to be detrimental to us. We only need to ask:

  1. Is this command really from Allaah? (authenticity)
  2. Do I understand what He wants me to do? (interpretation and application)

Once the answer is yes to both of these questions, there is no choice but to implement the command or believe it if it is information.

There is no harm in asking, in the appropriate manner, the wisdom behind certain commands of Allaah. However, even if the person cannot grasp it or the scholars could not deduce it, this lack of knowing the reason must not hinder a person from performing his duty towards the revelation, and it will not be accepted as a valid excuse for refusing to believe in it and follow it.

I hope this answers your question and I ask Allaah for guidance.

Finally, I would like to remind my brothers and sisters that using abbreviations like SWT, SAW, PBUH and so on are considered inappropriate and impolite. Instead, it is far better to either write the phrases in full or to leave them and pronounce them verbally, especially after the first instance.

And Allaah knows best.

References: 

[1] Tareeq-ul-Hijratayn, pp.873-874

[2] Tafseer of 17:15

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram