How do we address issues which are not mentioned in the Qur’an or Sunnah- like smoking?
Issues which are not dealt with in the Qur’an are solved by the principle of qiyas which is analogical deduction by using the principles from Qur’an and Sunnah to derive rulings on a particular issue.
With regards to smoking- it is haram. In the olden days it was considered makrooh. This ruling was made five hundred years ago. The scholars back then called it makrooh based on the effect it produces. Based on the knowledge they had, that smoking produces only bad breath, they looked at ruling for bad breath and found the hadith in which Ibn 'Umar reported: “The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said during the battle of Khyber: ‘He who ate of this plant, i.e. garlic, should not come to the mosques.’ [1]
In 1979 it was discovered that smoking causes cancer. The smoking companies were forced to put the warning that "Smoking causes Cancer" on cigarette packets. This new knowledge necessitated a change in the ruling because cancer leads to death. Whatever causes the loss of human life is haram, because one of the five major objectives of the Shari’ah is to preserve human life (hifz an-nafs). Therefore smoking is bad and evil and Allah the Almighty has divided things in the world into two types, good or permissible (al-tayyibaat, al-halal) and evil or prohibited (al-khabaa'ith, al-haram), and there is no third type.
Allah says:
"And He makes good things halal for them and bad things haram."[2]
Allah said:
"Do not kill yourself. Allah is Merciful unto you." [3]
In addition, His Prophet (ﷺ) said: "There is no harm or causing of harm (in Islam)." [4]
He also said: "A person will not be able to move on the Day of Judgment until he is asked about ... his body as to what he engaged it in." [5]
Smoking also goes against the saying of the Prophet (ﷺ): "Your body has a right on you." [6]
Some people may respond by saying that there is who smoke and yet they do not die or get affected by cancer. We say that Islam gives ruling based on general circumstances. Rulings are not based on exceptions to the general occurrences. For example there are people who have survived after jumping out of an airplane without carrying a parachute. This does not mean that everyone who jumps out of an aircraft without parachute will not die.
References:
[1] Transmitted by Muslim in his Saheeh, hadith No 1141, Book of prayers (Kitab us salat)
[2] Surah al-A'raaf , 7:157
[3] Surah al-Nisa', 4:29
[4] Ibn Majah, hadith number 2340, al-Hakim authenticated this hadith in his Al-Mustadrak, Vol 2 pg. 66
[5] At-Tirmithi, hadith number 2417, at-Tirmithi authenticated this hadith in his Sunan, Vol 4, pg 612
[6] Al-Bukhari: 1975
< Back to Questions