Some scholars in my area claim that bid'ah is not necessarily a bad thing and there are "bad" bid'ah and "good" bid'ah. The latter enhance the well-being of our community and contribute to the progress of the ummah. His reasoning is that there are many things done today that were not done during the time of the Prophet (sallallaahu alaihi wa sallam), such as using a loudspeaker for athaan to call people to salat, which do not fall into bad bid’ah category. Kindly explain.

  • The idea of good bid’ah is itself an innovation. The Prophet (ﷺ) said that every bid’ah is misguidance, and Ibn Umar qualified that and added, "Even if people regard it to be good."
  • The concept of a good bid’ah is shaky because every group which engages in bid’ah claims that their bid’ah is good bid’ah. Who then defines what is a good bid’ah and what is bad?
  • The argument that loudspeakers, cars, etc are bid’ah shows the importance of understanding hadeeth in its proper context. The hadeeth of A'isha makes it clear that it has to do with matters of religion. ‘Aisha (radhiyallahu anha) reported Muhammad (ﷺ) said: "Whoever innovates into this affair of ours something that we have not commanded it is to be rejected" [1]

Bid’ah only applies to acts of worship, not worldly things. When it comes to worldly things, everything is Halal until proven to be Haraam.

Reference: 

[1]  Bukhari and Muslim

< Back to Questions
If you liked the article, do leave a comment down below
IOU on Social Networks
facebook twittr youtubeinstagram